Is CAA and NRC Dangerous For India?
Is CAA and NRC Dangerous For India?
Hi guys firstly I am writing this article as an Indian citizen not as a Congress supporter or BJP hater.
Our home minister Mr. Amit shah said NRC will be applied to the entire country.
First, we see what are the advantages of CAA and NRC.
The main advantage of NRC is the illegal immigrants who infiltrated into India with the welfare benefits of the Indian poor, will be identified and compelled to go back.
The advantage of CAA is that the Hindu, Sikh, Buddhist, Farsi, Jain and Christen refugees from Bangladesh Pakistan and Afghanistan will get Indian citizenship.
Disadvantage of CAA and NRC.
Amit Shah said so many times that CAA has nothing to do with Indian citizens. Yes it’s true I also believe in that but It’s a combination of CAA and NRC which creates fear among the Indian Muslims. NRC Means, every citizen will be asked to prove that you are a citizen of India.
As proof, they will ask you some documents we can produce documents. What happened to 20% of people of India who lie in a poor category and they don’t have any documents.
One question arises that Why Indian Muslims creating issues if they are citizens then they can show their documents?
It’s not that simple. Let me explain with a diagram.
If Hindu, Sikh, Buddhist, Farsi, Jain, and Christen identifies as illegal immigrants through NRC then citizenship will be given them through CAB but it is not going to happen with Muslims. That’s why CAA and NRC are two sides of coin which creating fear among the Indian Muslims.
We saw Assam example one spelling mistake in documents can create many difficulties for the people. Citizens of Assam have to prove that either he, either his parents or his grandparents came to Assam before 24th March 1971. They also had to prove that he or she is related to his/her parents and his/her grandparents.
Now in that country where about 36 crores people live within 40 or 50 rupees every day
And where the prime minister cannot show his university degree, how will 135 crores of people prove their citizenship in that country.
Some people died in the protest against this act.
Some people suicide because of fear that they will not become stateless.
Every law has 3 aspects
1.legal aspect
2.social aspect
3.finanacial aspect
Now everyone talks about the first two aspects but the government not telling about the 3rd aspect i.e. financial aspect. NRC happened in Assam in that state where 3.06 crores people live and which acquire India’s 2.4 % geographical area which took 10 years. Assam NRC coated around 1220 crores. If we calculate the cost for NRC per person in Assam
Cost per person in asam=1220 crore/3.06 crore
= 399 rupees
then it gives 399 rupees/person. If we calculate for the whole country then we have to multiply India’s population and cost per person ie 137crores*399 then it comes 54663 crores that’s nothing but ₹ 546630000000.
So the entire country NRC will cost approx ₹546630000000 rupees.
Is it okay to do it when the country’s economy is in trouble?
Is it okay to do it when the core sector is in negative growth?
Is it okay to do it when the manufacturing sector is in trouble?
Is it okay to do it when the Highest unemployment in 45 years?
I think there is no need for CAA and NRC because according to census 11 in more than 500 out of 640 districts in India illegal immigration is under 0.5%. if the government put the same efforts into our employment issues, health, education, an economy that will be better for our future.
“It is just like that you are hungry very hard and you asked your father for a biscuit and the father picked you up and put you on the freezer And forgetting to ask for the biscuits, you tell the father to get down from the freezer”
I written both advantages and disadvantages now you decide is caa and nrc are dangerous or not?
Comment me below what’s your opinion on CAA and NRC.
Follow me on instagram @thevinaysirsal for regular updates related to my post.
Originally published at https://vinaysirsal.blogspot.com on February 29, 2020.
